*** Here at TransportBlog we’re big advocates for making Auckland more “family friendly”. In general, this means designing our city to be safe and pleasant for the most vulnerable people: Children. While many parts of Auckland are a long way from idal, the City Centre has – in my opinion – come a long way over the last 10-15 years, I’m struck by the number of families and children I now see wandering around enjoying all that the city has to offer. This post documents the experiences of one such family. Edward and his family have lived in an apartment in the City Centre for almost a decade. This post provides a glimpse into their experiences, warts and all. We hope it encourages decision-makers (elected representatives and public servants) to continue to “family proof” Auckland, while also encouraging more families to consider living in the City Centre. As Edward notes, there are some significant upsides to living in an apartment. Less time spent maintaining property and/or travelling = more time spent with loved ones. ***

My name is Edward and this is a photo of my son eating a Popsicle while watching cricket on a large screen down at Britomart.

watching the cricket at Britomart

My son has spent all of his seven years living in an apartment in central Auckland. He goes to the only primary school in the city centre.

We are not particularly well served with playgrounds where we live. Until recently the closest playgrounds were Victoria Park (which he doesn’t rate highly – the equipment looks good but doesn’t offer good climbing challenges); Wynyard Quarter (which is fun because there are a lot of other kids playing here on the weekends); and Gladstone Park (opposite the Parnell Rose Gardens, which is a hidden gem with long slides and climbing apparatus).

The newly upgraded playground in Myers Park is a great addition to the city centre. Last time we visited there were about 40 people of all ages using the playground, with the large swing especially thrilling for children of my son’s age. The primary issue with Myers Park is the poor pedestrian connections to Aotea Square, which makes it less easy and safe to get to the park from that direction.

Living in the City Centre has encouraged us to to improvise. We wade through every water feature we can find, climb a lot of the pohutukawa trees, and play on the steps of buildings. Indeed, it’s almost as it the city is his playground. The photo below shows us enjoying Auckland Anniversary activities on Queen Street.

Auckland Aniversary activities on Queen St

Cycling is particularly important to us: It allows us to roam further afield and unlock more places to explore and play. From our apartment we can easily reach the Parnell Baths and Pt Erin Pools within 20 to 30 minutes away along mostly flat routes with only about five road crossings to tackle. We take cycle paths when they are available but we will bike on footpaths, parks, squares and shared spaces to get where we are going.As a parent, however, I’m aware of how the design of our streets creates unsafe situations for children.

Britomart Farmers Market

Pt Erin pools

The city centre is alive in the weekends and we try to make the most of it. But when we need quiet time it is easy to retire to our apartment and shut out the noise.

There are so many activities for him to do. Every year we go to the Diwali, Lantern and buskers festivals. During the Lantern Festival we ate dinner in Albert Park and walked home in 10 minutes, with none of the stress and hassle involved in driving through traffic and having to park miles away. In December we walked to the Domain to Christmas in the Park.

We have been spoilt over the last few years and now the idea of driving somewhere and searching for a car park when we get there seems like too much hard work, so we try to avoid it if we can. When we feel like an excursion we tend to take the ferry to Devonport or a bus to Takapuna. On a recent weekend we took the ferry to Waiheke, which simply involves a 5 minute walk to the Downtown ferry terminal.

Winter activities are a bit scarcer. We swim at the Tepid Baths or the Newmarket Pool (after mid-day when the smaller pool is released from lesson duties), visit the Art Gallery or  library, and attending the great Pick & Mix activities at the Aotea Centre on Saturday mornings. The Britomart farmers market on Saturday morning at Tukatai Square also has a great hum and there are always other children there. I’m interested to know whether they also live in apartments nearby or whether they are simply visiting.

The primary thing the city lacks is other children.

He is the only child in our apartment building. Pregnancies begun and babies have appeared but they have all disappeared into the suburbs within a short time. Children come into the city whenever there are events on or to visit Wynyard Quarter but we don’t see regular faces on a day-to day basis. The birthday parties he attends are all in the suburbs, as is his sport and extra activities he has participated in. Cricket at Victoria Park would be the closest organized sport he could attend or tennis at Parnell (the closest tennis club at Stanley St doesn’t have a children’s holiday programme).

I think his life will be more interesting if he had friends living nearby. I understand the Pioneer Women’s and Ellen Melville Hall on Freyberg Place will provide a space for children’s activities soon. I hope so. We will support it if it does. The recent closure of Quay Street was a fun opportunity for us to explore a place that is usually hostile to families.

Cycling around on a closed Quay St 2

Some people are unsure how to treat kids in the City. Security guards tell him to stop playing on steps because he could fall and hurt himself. Adults tell him to walk on the edges of shared spaces because a car might drive down it.

Apartment living has many aspects we like. We can lock up and go away for the weekend without too much effort. We don’t have to spend time commuting or maintaining our property. We are lucky that we have a lot of friendly people in our building willing to give my son some attention. I know more of my neighbours than I ever did when living in the suburbs. The city centre has most shops we need. I do need to get in a car if we want things from a hardware shop.

Living in an apartment means I spend a lot of time with my son, which I see as a good thing. But it is not just the quantity of time we spend together, but also the quality of time – both of us enjoy the interesting things on our doorstep together, with little to no stress involved. Living in a smaller space encourages us to get outside more and experience the spontaneous entertainment one often encounters in the city.

It is different from my childhood in Hawkes Bay and I am constantly looking for signs of deprivation, but so far I haven’t found any.

Share this

43 comments

  1. Nice piece Stu – certainly resonates with my experience of living in the city albeit I don’t have kids. It certainly raises the issue of encouraging the development of an inner city that is family friendly because cities that respond to the needs of family are the ones that encourage people to stop, linger, enjoy and have a genuine sense of safety and comfort about them.
    Not sure if you have caught up that there is a Neighbours Day Event happening at the Pioneer Women’s Hall and Freyberg Square for apartment dwellers living within the immediate city, Saturday 28 March 11am – 3pm. Might be your and your and your neighbours proverbial cup of tea, a variety of activities going down – all in a neighbourly fashion.

  2. Central Auckland needs some more activites during the winter months. Living in central Auckland we find ourselves heading further afield in the winter to find things to do.

  3. Lack of other kids as you point out is probably the main issue, though will no doubt change with time.

    A couple of questions:

    Do you let your kid out of the apartment by himself (and if so from what age and far is he allowed to go, if not, when will that change). The main difference is obviously the lack of your own yard where a young kid can play. I didn’t actually read the article but there was something recently about parents letting their young kids walk around NY to go to Central Park to play etc.

    Does your complex have any facilities (gym, pool, tennis court). Does your apartment have outdoor areas (patio or deck). I assume you own – if you knew you were going to have kids when you bought, would you have had different requirements – what should developers be including to ensure complexes are family friendly.

    1. Its a good post. Thanks Edward.

      When I was in NYC some 3 years ago now, I saw kids riding the Subway trains with soccer balls in their hands, obviously going to or from Central Park which was a few stops down the line.

      Whether an adult accompanied them I can’t recall now, but those kids looked quite at home riding the subway from their apartments to get to a “local” park.

      1. My kids have always had free range of the city… I reckon it’s much less risky for them than the mall, or empty suburban streets, and never had any kind of, I don’t what?, stranger danger?, is that what suburbanites think the risk is in the city? We have had issues with our kids’ friends’ parents freaking out that we let them go unchaperoned in the city, or rather where ever they want on their bikes or on transit. Meh, that’s their problem….

    2. Moved to inner city 15 years ago with 2 kids 9/10 years old. We were considered a novelty being apartment dwellers at that time. Had no hesitation letting the kids wander down the hill to Queen St to spend their pocket money. My dad (80-odd, Timaru) was horrified. Everything he knew about Auckland was from TV shows, like a police reality show that used to feature all the drunken mayhem in the middle of the night.

      But in fact downtown is far safer than empty suburbs and small towns. Always felt perfectly safe wandering around Piccadilly and Leicester Square at midnight with crowds of people filling the bars and restaurants after a night at the theatre. But have felt intimidated in New Plymouth alone with a gang of menacing thugs eyeing me up.

      1. And the suburbs have the additional danger of fast moving traffic, something seen far less downtown now. Most people have a blind spot about this. Terrified of crime but curiously accepting of the far greater risk of death or injury from traffic.

  4. Terrific post, thanks Edward, so great to hear how kids can live right in town. It made me realise that when there are no free summer-in-the-city it is a bit lonely and child-free, and that all the new apartment developments are aimed very squarely at young singles/couples and/or empty nesters. Great that you’ve added to the dialogue.

  5. It would be great if there were more families in the CBD but it would probably mean the end of shared spaces.

    1. Yes we’d finally get full pedestrianisation….I’d love to see more streets closed to traffic and full of children playing alone or while their parents have a coffee nearby. Certainly better than streets full of rat runners and parked cars as most of the CBD current stands.

    2. I love your sarc, mf.

      Take a look at Japanese cities, and their shared laneway spaces. Kids, cars, bikes. Sweet.

      Better still, take a look at the shared spaces immediately next to the Wynyard play area. I watched my toddlers with their two friends playing right next to the road this weekend. Slowed the traffic down a treat, just what is needed in shared spaces. Was I worried? Yes, a little – Auckland drivers are generally not known for their collective skills in dealing with people walking around them – but it works. And my kids came back unscathed and all the better for being part of the action. Bring it on.

      1. Yes you let your kids play beside cars and you got away with it this time. Well done you! What doesn’t kill them makes them stronger and all that… until it kills them. I promise if there were worried parents living in the CBD the very first thing they will do is form a neighbourhood watch and once they know each other the second is campaign to sort out traffic dangers. Shared spaces would be gone quickly as no politician is going to debate child safety with upset parents. No surprises they only exist in the CBD.

        1. Yeah; No kid ever got run over in the ‘burbs… it’s so safe there, it’s not like there’s a driveway every 10 metres or so. Are you serious? Suburbia is the place for killing kids with cars; it’s perfectly designed to achieve it- by traffic engineers.

      2. Sounds like some free range parenting in action. I understand how difficult that can be, were there other adults around looking horrified?

  6. I’m one of those that had to leave the city after the kid was born. Apartment was too small, too noisy and too expensive. We didn’t care about that before the kid came, because we would be out all day and eat out often, and two incomes were good. Once you have a grizzly baby that doesn’t sleep well you realize how noisy rush hour is and how much soot collects on the balcony. (I bet they don’t keep that in consideration when investing in wider motorways instead of rail tunnels).
    Also inner streets are too scary with a pram, long way to go.
    We now live just outside the cbd, because suburbia is my partner’s biggest fear. Good on ya for sticking to it though.

  7. Great post. Thanks Edward for sharing. More kids would be great. I like having the kids getting about on their skateboards. There’s plenty to do for everyone in the city.

  8. Beaumont Quarter has a monthly kids/parents picnic for residents with 20+ kids turning up each time, and so many babies that we have our own coffee group that is only a minute walk away.

  9. Great post Edward. I think of you as a new world Explorer or even potential martyr. I’m very interested in the events or thought processes that lead you and your family to your current lifestyle. I can only assume that as a youth, like most nzers, you may have pictured your future family playing in the yard of a quarter acre section waiting for you to pull up in the driveway in your SUV.

    At what point did you decide to divert from the collective idealisation of the ‘kiwi dream’ to raise a son in an area that until recently has been nothing more than a wind swept central business district? Did you expect significant challenges? Had you anticipated the vibrancy and quality of life that you seem to be experiencing?

  10. He is a lucky boy, i spent far to much of my youth in a small hicktown. Cities always seemed far more desirable to me from as long ago as i can remember.

  11. If there were more kids in an apartment building you could ask for an inside playing ground like shopping malls have would have limits but good for under s5 and wet days

  12. Is there a chance that we could make this a 6-monthly or annual post so we can see how the boys use of the city develops as he ages?

    1. Totally. That’s something you really notice when you’re out at night in Spain or Portugal. Because there are kids out with their parents having dinner till midnight, the streets feel much safer and more friendly.

  13. I have lived in a city apartment for a year, but have had a bad experience, the floor creaks and the neighbors always complain, I cant even walk around the place without freaking out about making noise. pretty stink for almost $450pw. I think its just that place though; but I am moving back to the suburbs in winter, for some more space and so I can ride the nice new trains to work every day, and hopefully every night home when doing evening shifts (hopefully they remove the 10:30 curfew soon and run them at least an hour longer). No kids… yet, thank god otherwise the neighbors (below) would be busting down my door haha. Don’t even get me started on the noise, constantly hearing cars zoom past, screaming and emergency service sirens every few minutes, even worse is that irritating base music drumming in your ears from miles away, not my cup of tea being raised in a quiet west suburb, and really bad for my already poor lack of sleep.

    I will consider living in the city center again if they build really well-sound-proofed buildings that have easy access to PT and bit more space and greenery.

    1. Sounds like a pretty crap building. Most would have concrete floors (which I hope dont creak!) and proper sound proofing.

      The only issue with noise should be if you want to open a window. Because of this, some form of air con unit is important.
      Soot on the deck is another issue.

    2. I agree with Harvey – most of the apartments I’ve been in have had very few problems with noise. I’ve got neighbours with a baby next door to my current one, and I’ve never once heard it through the walls (and only very occasionally in the corridor). Most apartments are pretty well soundproofed.

  14. Great post. Though I can’t see how the CBD is safe for kids to wander around alone. Too busy with vehicles and strangers compared with the suburbs. I think the CDB is still too bleak to have my children grow up in.

    1. The stranger danger works in a paradox. The more strangers around you, the less danger.

      The vehicles, I don’t know about that. You get a lot of them too in the suburbs. At least in the CBD it’s usually not too far to the next controlled crossing.

  15. We’re here! I love growing my daughter in k Rs, I had lived here for the main part of ten years prior so saw no need to leave. I love the community and the engagement in her life.
    Having recently started school I am bemused (and thankful) that locals want to take turns helping her with her homework and reaso g to her. Yes to other children, but the friends we have made (via Myers park, the library, the Sunday art programme and now school) are fabulous, fun, and diverse! (And I admit to making the most of her being a slight novelty so people are wanting to engage and involve)
    For those wondering if they can, I say yes! Ditch the car, grab your helmet and discover this amazing city!

  16. The lack of sports clubs is a bit problematic, although some sports lend themselves to being played indoor (tennis, netball etc) so that could be remedied as time goes by and demand builds up. Unfortunately certain sports that need a large area will always be relegated to the suburbs and that makes it even more important to ensure those grounds and venues are protected and not earmarked for development.

      1. The cricket pitches in the Domain couldn’t be closer if they were on top of each other. Victoria Park has four whole fields for soccer and rugby to share in Winter. How do you think that’s going to work out as inner-city density increases? Sorry, but I struggle to place that on the same level as Colin Maiden or Lloyd Elsmore Parks.

        1. although to be fair I can’t think of a major city in Australia that has major open access sports fields as close to the city centre as Auckland?

  17. Great post. Thanks for sharing your family’s experience Edward.
    In December the Waitematā Local Board become the first of Auckland’s local boards to be nominated and registered as ‘child friendly’ through the international UNICEF ‘Child Friendly Cities’ accreditation process. UNICEF defines a child friendly city as “a local system of good governance committed to fulfilling children’s rights. It is a city where the voices, needs, priorities and rights of children are an integral part of public policies, programmes and decisions. It is, as a result, a city that is fit for all”.

    The Board recently hosted a workshop with Dr Rodney Tolley (Conference Director of Walk21 and active, sustainable transport expert) to discuss what is needed for a child-friendly city. He recommends that controlling speeds should be at the heart of our child- friendly initiatives.

    1. Hi Pippa thanks for dropping by and good to hear that WLB is developing the city for children.

      Controlling speeds would be an obvious one, as would simply either 1) removing slip lanes from intersections or 2) installing signalised crossings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *