Yesterday’s post about promoting the section of Great North Road between Grey Lynn and Karangahape Road as a high priority area for intensification generated a lot of interesting comments. It would seem that generally there was a lot of support for the idea, although with some justified mention that the impact of more people on existing schools in the area needs to be taken into consideration. This is fairly obvious, and I would suggest that it’s probably a lot more cost-effective for the Ministry of Education to add buildings to existing schools in these inner suburbs than it is for them to acquire land and build brand new schools in areas on the urban periphery like Flat Bush.
Another corridor which seems as though it could be suitable for a similar type of redevelopment (and also where such development is starting to happen) is along the inner portion of New North Road, between Kingsland and Newton:
Much like the Great North Road corridor, which is located just across the other side of the Northwest Motorway, this corridor runs through an area with fairly high land values and pretty good public transport. Aside from a few places along the route (particularly up near Symonds Street) there’s not too many heritage constraints on the corridor either, as long as we’re sensitive about how development interacts with adjacent residential areas. So in terms of viability and attractiveness, it seems logical to assume that intensification would “work” here. The approximate location of both corridors I’ve looked at so far in comparison to land-values around Auckland is shown below:
The two black lines show the roads we’re talking about intensifying along – which generally site within the orange areas showing fairly high land values (and therefore the incentive to make the most out of the high land values).
A fairly typical street scene from this area is shown below – not altogether dissimilar to what we have just over on the other side of the valley along Great North Road:
Plus of course we also have the infamous interchange with Dominion Road which is crying out for something to happen to it (as described in more detail here):
Tightening up this interchange into a normal intersection would free up an enormous amount of land, plus reintegrate Kingsland with Eden Terrace and create a much nicer urban environment around here.
We have started to see a few apartment developments occurring along New North Road over the past few years – the one below is on the site of an old petrol station that closed down around five years ago:
Looking closely at the sign shows that the two bedroom apartments were selling for around $410,000 – what you might expect for such a development to stack up financially. We’re not talking shoebox apartments here either I imagine. This development has 40 units on around 1,200 square metres – only 30 square metres of land per unit.
And once again, you can see that this development forms only a small proportion of what I might call the general intensification area – although perhaps to a greater extend than along Great North Road many opportunities here have already been taken up (especially close to town):
The Dominion Road/New North Road intersection could become quite a hub for development around this part of Auckland if it was turned back into something more normal. The Newton Station will also, once the City Rail Link is built, be a huge hub for development.
Processing...
I certainly agree with you. I’d go up a block or two in Kingsland, to the top of the slope on the Kingsland side. I also think it’s worth adding in the short section of Mt Eden Rd to the base of the Mt in this section, as well as perhaps the few streets behind (Normanby, etc), leaving enough space around the prison. They make sense as a coherent whole. Then you’ve got a nice, fairly coherent string of large enough size to work with. Great work though!
It’s interesting that you skip a portion of Tawari Street, shown here.
http://maps.google.com/maps?q=akepiro+street&hl=en&ll=-36.870545,174.749636&spn=0.000852,0.001206&oe=utf-8&client=firefox-a&hq=akepiro+street&t=h&z=20&vpsrc=6
However this site already has an apartment building under construction on it.
As for your idea. I like it. Essentially you have Kingsland and Newton as anchoring town centres. These will provide hubs for transport, bars, restaurants etc. I live in the zone that you specify and I would love to be able to buy an apartment here as it really is ideal for my lifestyle.
Although that apartment block has been trying to sell those apartments at around $400,000 since pre the GFC,
they wanted $410-440 in 2007.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/city-style-real-estate/news/article.cfm?c_id=148&objectid=10460450
They’re 51-56 sqm, according to your link. That’s not a lot of space for the money given current prices. But I’m surprised anyone would buy one. They’re in the middle of a light industrial area. That’s great if you need a new muffler, but most apartment dwellers want to be able to walk to restaurants and other entertainment venues. I think new apartment developments are more likely to be built on the edges of existing high density residential and entertainment areas. They’ll gradually replace industry by expanding the residential area. I think dropping apartments in to the middle of an industrial area is a bad idea. I think it is unrealistic to expect an industrial area to spontaneously change in to a mixed residential and entertainment area. The exception is if the industrial area is essentially derelict, such as you see in parts of Manchester and London.
I live in that industrial area. It’s great. On the weekend everything is shut so it is really quiet and it’s only a 10 minute walk to Kingsland, Valley Road or Newton.
Although I do agree, that it is expensive for what they are. If they were 350ish I would be all over it. BTW that street is actually residential at that end.
Wrong apartment block. That one is on New North Road. The one I am talking about is under construction off Tawari Street. I’d prefer that myself as the streets up on the hill are much quieter.
This is a great idea. How would it look if light rail was running down Dominion Road to link to the area as well?
All this area was blighted by Spaghetti Junction for decades of course. Yet more illustration of the costs of a roads first policy.
I think this place is perfect for a new town centre to occur. The high apartment population will almost certainly attract businesses around the new intersection so long as provision is made for a business zone. I strongly believe that a spontaneous flood of investment in the area is possible provided certain conditions are met and light rail goes up Dominion Rd and down Queen Street. This development could be a precedent for a new kind of urban living that will be attractive to the younger generation.