For years Wellington has been NZ’s public transport capital and one of the main things that helped it stand out was it was the one city in the country with a semi decent train service. Auckland on the other hand has been considered the city of cars and trains were considered such a joke that many people didn’t even know they existed. Things have been starting to change in Auckland though, over the last 8 years since Britomart opened patronage has rocketed from around 2.5 million per year to 9.5 million now. March alone has seen patronage smash through the 1 million trips in a month milestone recording 1.118 million passengers.
This got me thinking about how it compares to Wellington. A quick search was able to uncover Wellingtons patronage stats for each month from July 1999 to June 2010, further searching uncovered the % growth of rail patronage for Feb and March 2011. This allowed me to plot the rail patronage for each city against each other (although there is a gap for Wellington from July 2010 to January 2011).
As you can see patronage in Auckland is rapidly catching up and if the current trends continue then we are likely to see train usage in Auckland pass that of Wellington within the next year or two which is before we even get the electric trains running. Even more interesting is that March’s record result is better than all but two months from Wellington, March 2009 and 2011. We do need to remember that Wellington is about to get a bit of a boost from its new trains which are just starting to come online however I don’t think that will be enough to stop Auckland passing them.
It will be interesting to see the reaction when it is announced that Auckland has more train journeys than Wellington, will it be what is finally needed to change the thinking of some of the dinosaurs out there who still think that rail in Auckland doesn’t work? Of course there will still be plenty of knockers and we can expect to hear the argument that per capita Auckland still lags far behind but hopefully those negative voices will become increasingly isolated.

Processing...
Wellington’s rail has suffered from poor reliability in the last year or two, pushing its number down. The Matangis should bounce that up again but as you say it’s inevitable that Auckland will end up overtaking Welly at some point. We just have much more potential growth.
Yeah that’s where I got the numbers from for this comparison, its a shame it isn’t kept up to date.
Ross asked me to delete the post Matt’s reply is to as he hadn’t noticed that. Just to clear up any confusion.
Yes that is true however based on the last 12 years from the information I could find, March 2011 is the biggest month Wellington has ever had at 1.165m journeys meaning Auckland is less than 50k journeys behind. One thing to remember is that it will take some time before all of the Matangis are operational for for some time they will be only replacing older sets that will be decommissioned. Also don’t forget that Auckland has had constant reliability problems for many years yet is still growing strong.
“March 2011 is the biggest month Wellington has ever had at 1.165m journeys”
The extension to Waikanae would have opened in February or March. Most people using it to travel to Wellington CBD would have driven or bused to Paraparaumu to board the train so they wouldn’t have generated extra trips. But it is a more attractive option so will have induced some demand. Certainly my parents say they’ve been taking more free pensioner trips in to the city. On the other hand the local bus that took them to the shops at Paraparaumu now drops them at Waikanae station where they’re expected to travel one stop on the train and they think that isn’t as good.
The thing about Wellington’s train network is that it doesn’t service Wellington City at all. It really is more a service to get people from the two Hutts, Porirua and Kapiti to one end of Wellington CBD. In that way it is actually inferior to Auckland’s network which actually services the inner suburbs as well as the outer.
Wellington’s network is also incredibly focused on Wellington station. I think around 90% of trips either begin or end at Wellington station, whereas around 40% of rail trips in Auckland begin and end outside the CBD. On the Western Line apparently the majority of trips don’t begin or end at Britomart.
Well hopefully WGTN’s mayor can get that system extended with light rail…. if the Joyce’s thugs can be reigned in.
Your post does raise the question though, without any new track due to be laid any Auckland anytime soon, what are the limits on this recent revival?
1. First there is the limited reach of the network. This can be expanded through the development of bus interchange stations and connection to improved bus networks as is planned at Panmure and underway at Manukau.
2. There is the physical constraint of the big choke point in the network, the Britomart terminus. Build the CBD Rail Line
3. There is the finite quantity of rolling stock, although these could be worked harder, especially off peak, if funding allows.
4. Which brings us to the financial constraint imposed by a hostile minister of transport which limits our ability to achieve any of the above. All roads lead to Rome. The problem is, in contrast to almost every leader everywhere in the twenty first century, like Mayor Bloomberg of New York City, this government does not see raising rail use as a good thing in it self.
Still I don’t think we will see a drop off in growth, especially if we can keep improving the small things, especially integration with busways, and ticketing. This is going to be increasingly irresistible… The externalities [costs of driving] and improvements to service will continue.
Good letter in the herald this morning by Russell Baillie too.
The limit after electrification is 22.2m passengers per year which we will hit in around 10 years (however peak services will be pretty crowded long before then) see http://greaterakl.wpengine.com/2011/02/01/cbd-tunnel-behind-the-scenes/
So the CBDRL study reckons we can more than double current numbers with the existing set up, post electrification. Well we’ll have to be able to improve off peak services and frequencies in general….
Yes that’s very true Patrick. We can have significantly longer trains though – so that boosts passenger capacity. Electrification boosts speed which also results in capacity increases.
But yeah, apparently the biggest growth rates are off peak due to capacity constraints at peak times.
Interesting. But has the numbers been ‘normalised’ to take into account the differences in population?
As I said on a per capita basis Wellington is still far ahead of Auckland. Based on current population Auckland would have to have 34 million trips to have more trips per person than Wellington and due to the limitations of the rail network at present it is something we will only be able to achieve with the CBD tunnel
I think a clearer picture will be found by comparing Rail use with things including population, month, job location etc. (Obviously one for the statistician.)
I have all of the population data for both cities broken down by month attached to these figures, in that regard Wellington is still far ahead of Auckland but the whole point of this post is that soon Aucklands train network will be carrying more than that of Wellington’s, something most would have laughed at 10 years ago.
So why is train patronage higher in Wellington when Auckland is presumably a bigger and denser city?
They didn’t abandon their public transport program’s like Auckland did.
Wellington’s topography suits high-capacity corridors – there are only two routes in from the rest of the region, so the demand gets focussed into rail-friendly high flows (and those high-demand corridors combine and continue through the linear CBD but with an enforced change of PT mode at the CBD-peripheral railway station, making Wellington ideal for city-centre rail extension, like tram-trains).
On the other hand Auckland spreads in many directions, and the consequent dispersed demand isn’t ideal for rail.
But in one respect Auckland is already ahead of Wellington – the regular 15-minute off-peak frequency between Britomart/Westfield and Papakura is better than anything in the capital. The nearest it gets is 3 trains an hour, and not regularly spaced, between Petone & Wellington – and there are 6 buses each hour.
Just to add to what Mike said… Development north and north west of Wellington city is essentially concentrated in to two valley corridors. The one north of the harbour must be 20-30km long and probably not more that 5km across at the very widest and mostly much narrower than that. I don’t have figures to prove it, but I suspect there is very little employment related travel between the two corridors. Instead most employment travel will be within each corridor or in to the regional center. Both scenarios suit rail.
Having said that, someone posted a link to the Wellington Regional Council transport plan a day or two ago, and one of the things in it was a new road between Petone and Tawa that I hadn’t heard of before. That would encourage movement between corridors.
“the… point of this post”: Please don’t take this as a nitpick/insult, but I was responding to the comment about the “differences in population” above mine. I was not disputing the focus on passenger numbers. (No hard feelings!)
Its not surprising really, considering the huge difference in population and the continuing improvement to Aucklands rail system. Not to mention, as someone else did, that Wellingtons rail system doesnt actually service any of Wellington city itself, instead brings people from Hutt, Porirua etc into Wellington. Thats why light rail in Wellington city would be quite good.
Wellington’s rail actually serves a lot of the city, with its own Johnsonville line, well-used stations on the NIMT, and Ngauranga on the Wairarapa Line – by my count 14 stations within the city boundaries.
@Brisurbane – Wellington has had an electrified commuter rail network since the 1930’s. Auckland has had a (until recently) totally neglected and decaying urban rail network. Since some investment has been put into Auckland’s rail network over the last decade patronage has begun to climb.
Most of the Hutt Valley and also much of Porirua was specifically developed around the rail network. Also Wellington’s CBD has approximately as many employees as Auckland’s – naturally assisting rail.
I sometimes wonder if the ‘success’ of Wellington’s rail system is in part to blame for govt. politicians not understanding what is wrong with Britomart as a terminus. There is a tendency to see rail as all about commuting in and out in a suit, like in Welly. the land of commuting state apparatchiks. Whereas it’s what’s most in need of fixing in both cities.