Quite possibly for the first time ever, rail patronage in March broke the magical 1 million trips figure. According to data from Auckland Transport (not yet on their website) there were 1,118,000 rail trips on the Auckland network during March. This represents almost 200,000 more trips than March last year – which was previously the busiest month on record. That’s a 22% increase!

There were 7,065,000 total trips on the PT network for March 2011, an 8% increase on March 2010. It’s not known yet how much of the increase was on ferries and how much on buses, nor how well the Northern Express did (especially as the NEX was starting to hit capacity throughout March). That brings the 12 month rolling patronage pretty close to 65 million – something that we should crack in the next few months if April, May and June continue the trend of the last few months and give us big increases on the same month in 2010.

The table below compares rail patronage in January, February and March over the past nine years. Even over just the last four years we have seen patronage double in March: from 555,000 in 2007 to 1.118 million this year.While the 8% growth in total public transport patronage isn’t quite as dramatic as the 22% increase in rail patronage, it still indicates a pretty busy month – breaking through 7 million trips for definitely the first time in quite a few decades:
One does wonder how much more capacity there is in the rail system for patronage to keep growing. Particularly at peak times it would seem that the trains are often stuffed to capacity – perhaps we will see a spreading of the peak load as people look to avoid the most overcrowded services. If Auckland Transport provided a half-decent weekend service, plus better frequencies later into the evening, then I would imagine that patronage can continue to grow at these times – but until we can significantly increase the number of trains running on the system (which of course requires the CBD Tunnel) there’s probably going to come a point in the relatively near future where such dramatic patronage increases on the rail network are no longer possible.

I look forward to seeing the full data published by Auckland Transport next week when they have their April board meeting.

Share this

32 comments

  1. Pretty stunning growth, that puts the daily average trips per day including weekends at around 36,000 but based on info AT have said in the past about weekend patronage then we are probably seeing weekday patronage at about 43,000 per day.

    One thing that should be pointed out is that this year we haven’t had Easter fall in March so that would also help.

  2. Wow. Train patronage is six times what it was less than a decade ago.

    Given that there is only so much road, and it’s being filled up, this doesn’t seem surprising. With more investment in capacity, we could see that double or triple easily.

    1. Key words George D: ‘more investment’ can someone tell the minister, or perhaps his boss, that he needs to get with the programme here, and get the money to support the need not his mates and prejudices.

  3. The increase in rail trips since 2002 is staggering. Regardless of electrification problems, the rail tunnel, etc. I think Auckland should be very proud of what has happened in the last ten years!

  4. Yet despite all this growth, they still provide the 2002 service frequency on the Western Line on Saturdays, and still have no trains to Swanson on Sundays! Still, fantastic to see the million figure surpassed.

  5. I agree John. I remember in 2000 when I was 18, and someone telling me my sister was ‘catching the train to Henderson’. My reaction was ”Auckland has trains??”
    It seems Auckland has become very conscious of PT in the last 10 years, a huge change and something to proud of.

  6. Admin – Here is a really important question. How much have services increased since 1993, when we had only a million a year? I.e., what is the “elasticity” of the aesthetic improvements to trains and stations?

    1. Well certainly the quality of the service has increased vastly over that time. I think back in the early 90s there were really only peak hour trains on the Eastern and Western Lines (maybe a few inter-peak trains). The “late train” into town from the west was around 4.30pm in the afternoon.

    1. The metrics on the NZTA website all stop in 2006 too. They do not rely on census data so why is that? Driving everywhere in the OECD has contracted since around 2007, coincidence? Convenience?

      1. NZTA do monitor state highway trends all the time. Traffic on state highways in Auckland and Northland has decreased by around 1% since 2007.

  7. To Chris Harris

    How I remember the service having developed (I was the business analyst for Tranz Metro Auckland over some of this time):

    * Early-1990s – carriage trains, infrequent, running to the Strand stop when they ran at all. No Saturday trains. Annual patronage around 1m per year.

    * 1993 – introduction of the Perth trains – patronage improved over the next few years to about 2m passengers per year (still running, remember, into the Strand). Saturday trains (hourly) brought in during this time.

    * 2003 – Britomart opened – the breakthrough – and patronage increased to around 3m passengers per year in reasonably short order.

    I have been out of things for too long, so others will have to contribute here, but is the main scarce resource the numbers of trains/carriages, or paths into Britomart? If the latter – and new trains can be added fairly easily – then we may have to look at more trains looping round and using the Strand. Why? Well, one big difference between Wellington and Auckland, is that in Wellington, 90 percent of the 11m passengers per year are going into or out of Wellington station. In Auckland, only 50 percent or so are going into or out of Britomart, even at the peak.

    1. Ross, the scarce resource at the moment is both. We have the last four SA carriages coming online in the next month – and I think they’re simply going to make existing trains longer rather than adding any more trains onto the network. After that, unless some interim improvement can be found, there is no more available rolling stock until we get the electric trains – and we haven’t even signed the contract for their construction yet!

      Figures I’ve heard indicate that around 60% of rail trips in Auckland either start or end at Britomart. This varies according to the different line, with the lowest percentage being on the Western Line (then the Southern and then the Eastern). This means that some west-to-south services might be viable.

      In the long run though, there’s no way around the need for the CBD Tunnel to open up the capacity of the rest of the rail system.

      1. West-South services make sense to me as a way of lifting frequency if there is rolling stock available, until the CBDRL is online I think we should all get used to transferring at Newmarket as much as sitting in the carriage for three minutes.

        And can we not work the existing carriages a bit harder off-peak? Or is that constrained by Joyce’s cap on PT? I was on the western line at 10:40am today and that was pretty full…. an extra train an hour would make a huge difference to being able to just rock up and expect a reasonable wait….

        1. I think better off-peak frequencies is very much constrained by Joyce’s funding cap. At the same time, rail fares generally only covers around 29-30% of operating costs so we do need to work out ways of running the system more efficiently. Electric trains and a far less labour-intensive ticketing system should knock back operating costs significantly. It’s probably also a bit unreasonable to expect rail fares to stay lower than bus fares.

        2. Admin do you have any record of expectations or predictions for patronage from the last decade? Are things on track or better than expected?

        3. I have long supported introducing a handful of West-South direct services. The figure of 60% trips ending at Britomart is interesting since we all know how many business parks and employers are located outside of the CBD. The advantages to me are clear
          1) additional services can be put on without putting pressure on the Britomart chokepoint
          2) provides a quicker commute for people living west or south and working south or west, by eliminating the transfer time at Newmarket.
          3) offers a realistic rail option for south-west folk who would not consider using rail because of Newmarket timetabling. I suspect there is a sizeable market out there that is currently invisible. Like the invisible sector of the 83% road commuters back in 2004 who were deemed as never likely to ever use PT.

  8. will be very close to Wellingtons patronage. They had 1.08million March last year, but it has been mentioned anecdotally they have 10% growth, so they might just edge Auckland out.

  9. @Patrick

    Don`t know about patronage predictions or targets but I know that ARTA had targeted weekday late night services to begin in late 2010/2011. That was listed in one of their action plans around 2008/9. Of course constraints in PT funding surrounding the track fees etc looked to have scotched that except for maybe during the duration of the RWC.

    1. Better off-peak services cannot come soon enough. I work on top of the station, but I’m still left with buses as the best option if we have a late function or I have a meeting that runs a bit late. Since I’m at Ellerslie, if we get beyond 19:25 my rail choices to get home during the week are 20:12, 20:15, 21:10, 21:17, 22:10. Those are some very long gaps, and if it happens to be Friday I’m then given the wonderful choices of 23:10 and 00:10. Hourly. Awesome. Not.

      We have the rolling stock, we have the staff. Off-peak services could be improved fairly cheaply (last trains in Wellington are after 01:00 on Friday and Saturday nights, our last trains are around midnight, unless you want Onehunga in which case they’re about 23:00), and would help the general impression of rail amongst the city-going set.

  10. Given that rail patronage is exceeding expectations, will the new EMUs have sufficient capacity to cope? Won’t we need electric locomotives as well to haul the existing carriages?

    1. I have also heard that electric loco hauled SA trains are unlikely to be able to use the CBD tunnel. Which means we will have to work out what on earth to do with all those SA trains at some point.

      1. Waikato services. All you need to do is string up some wires, fix up the stations if not done already, and install some toilets on the SAs. Everything else will be existing at that point, track, electric locos, rolling stock.

        1. Bridge heights? Certainly there’s no issue of rated track weight, since it’s NIMT, but not sure if there are road bridges that would need to be accounted for.
          Electrifying the connection all the way to the Frankton yards would allow electric freight locos to run from Auckland to Palmy non-stop.

      2. I don’t think there is to much to worry about with the future of the SA trains, firstly they are already about 40 years old and even though they have been extensively refurbished they probably only have 10-15 years of life in them. The CBDRL is expected to be operational in about 10 years so that would work in well. The loco’s they will buy to pull them will by then be about 10 years old and could be ideal to use on the NIMT as by that time the existing electric locos will be 30-40 years old.

        As for the question of if we will have enough trains. The EOI stated the EMU’s should be 3 car sets with 24m long carriages so a total length per set of 72m, it also said there should be 250 seats per set. By comparison a current 4 car SA train has 260 seats and is 80m long while a 6 car set has about 380 seats. In most cases the new EMU’s will be operated as two sets together so 6 cars and 144m long with seating for about 500 people which is almost the capacity of an 8 car SA train.

        The plan is to run the EMU’s on the Western, Eastern and Onehunga lines with the loco hauled SA trains working on the Southern line. The number of trains seems about right, assuming that there is always 3 EMU’s out for servicing or for backup should something go wrong, 2 are needed for Onehunga, 10 trains are needed for the western line so 19 EMU’s mean that 9 of them can be 6 car trains, about 7 trains are needed for Manukau so the remaining 14 EMU’s mean all can 6 car trains. We will then need about 10 or 11 trains for the Southern line which means there will also be a couple of spare SA sets as backup. All of this hopefully means we don’t get into the situation Wellington is in where the demand is such that there isn’t the ability to rotate sets out for proper maintenance.

  11. Sometimes I just can’t believe how the government/NZTA seems to be ignoring the blatant trends in Rail/PT patronage in Auckland, despite being so underfunded for so long. Do they know something we dont?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *