There has been a lot of debate, discussion and distress in the last couple of weeks over the introduction of the HOP card. Another article, this time in the Dominion Post, highlights some of the problems facing the HOP card’s roll out over the next few months.

While the article mainly focuses on the potential for confusion over whether Wellington Snapper Cards will be able to be used on Auckland buses (the answer seems to be “yes” much to Auckland Transport’s annoyance), the last couple of paragraphs from the article are what worries me:

Auckland Transport spokeswoman Sharon Hunter said the Hop-branded Snapper cards could only be used to pay for public transport in Auckland until later this year, when Auckland Transport would replace them free-of-charge with a new type of Hop payment card that would also work on ferries and trains.

That card might in turn be phased out later in favour of a third type of payment card that could be used on public transport nationwide.

What what what???? So a current bus catcher with a GO Rider card will need to get a HOP/Snapper Card over the next few weeks, then later this year they’ll need to change cards to an upgraded HOP card (this time without the Snapper component) and in the future they might need to upgrade again to yet another card. What on earth is going on?

As I tried to outline last week, discussions I have had with various people on this matter have clarified that the first batch of HOP cards are basically rebranded Snapper Cards that will hook into the Snapper “system” for processing bus payments, top-ups and so forth. This is pretty much just like an upgraded GO Rider card, except that you’ll also be able to use it at various shops for small purchases. Contrary to what Auckland Transport might like, as the HOP card is basically a rebranded Snapper, there will be nothing technically stopping people from using a normal Snapper Card on the bus.

But this ‘interim system’ can’t last forever. Other bus companies are never going to buy into a system controlled by one of their direct competitors, while Thales were the company that actually won the tender for doing Auckland’s integrated ticketing system – not Snapper. So at some point we will need to switch over from the Snapper system to the Thales system. In a way it’s annoying that Snapper have thrown this ‘spanner in the works’, but if the ‘switch-over’ can be done smoothly then perhaps things would be OK: as at least we got a contactless smartcard a few months earlier this way.

The issue is how this ‘switch-over’ happens, and how many times it needs to happen. Ideally, the switch could just be a simple software change: perhaps on the changeover date when you swipe your card over a reader it shifts your balance from the Snapper account into the Thales system and updates the software on your card to the new system. While from a technical perspective that might be difficult, from a user-perspective that certainly seems to be the most painless way of doing it. Otherwise we are going to have stupid situations of some HOP card working and others not working.

As for having to then change your upgraded HOP card for yet another card at some point down the track – let’s not even go there!

Share this

34 comments

  1. Sounds like a gigantic mess…

    It might be simpler to just stick with paper for the meantime- you can get integrated fares (one price for all modes within zones) and integrated ticketing (one ticket for all modes) all on paper. That’s how we did it until the bugs were banished from out Smartcard system. And there are always cost blowouts and glitches with SmartCards- always! They can become very expensive, all consuming debacles. All stops should be pulled out to prevent this happening.

  2. That would be a ridiculous situation. Hopefully it will be just a software change. As others have pointed out, Oyster has taken years to fully roll out its current capabilities with overground train companies, but I’m pretty sure you never had to keep swapping your Oyster every time there was a change to the system. I’ve had mine since 2007.

  3. As part of the deal to use the Hop name for Snapper, I wonder if NZ Bus have a contractural obligation to move to the “new” Hop system when it finally appears? Otherwise what’s to stop them saying “no thanks, we’re quite happy with our system and don’t want to change”. I suspect there will have to be a big sweetener to get all the bus companies on board.

    1. You mean a big sweetener like “When your contract comes up for renewal in 2014, it will include a non-negotiable, day-zero requirement to be using HOP”?

      NZ Bus has done wonderfully at pissing off the Auckland transport community, and Auckland Transport will be holding all the cards when the next contract renewal comes around. Dropping NZ Bus would not upset very many people.

      1. Except that we’re talking about 2012, not 2014, and there are other companies apart from NZ Bus who could take the same position.

  4. Makes you wonder why they bothered branding the Snapper card as Hop. Why not just let NZ Bus roll out Snapper as the replacement to Go Rider? Now there is a danger if there are problems with the Auckland Snapper roll out, then it looks like Auckland Transport’s problem!?

  5. Why are they doing it this way? It makes no logical sense.

    And I can’t see it being a simple software change. While it may be possible on a technical level, it would give a Thales card with a Snapper logo still printed on it, which I don’t think will be commercially and/or politically acceptable to a number of organisations involved.

    What a PR and organisational trainwreck.

  6. Yeah we have to deal with all that when there is open source transport smart cards with many off the shelf products supporting it – see http://www.calypsonet-asso.org/

    It makes me wonder why we had to pay a French defence company multi-millions of dollars when we could have got a kiwi varsity to spin off a company and employ a dozen smart IT graduates and work out the best way to use the open source system for NZ conditions. A smart government department (rather than the NZTA) would have done exactly that and worked with the transport minister on legislation to support a roll-out that held the crazy-arsed commercial operators in check.

    It will take a while for all this confusion with multi-branded cards to settle down, and if we are very, very lucky we’ll end up with a national scheme of integrated ticketing. If we are lucky.

  7. When you use your computer – do you upgrade your software from time to time? Do you upgrade apps on your phone? Are there upgrades if you use a navman or similar?

    The HOP card is being phased in. International experience shows the big bang apporach is not the way to go. Phases (1) HOP brand introduced with swap out of Go Rider cards and use on the largest bus company- NZ Bus. (2) HOP card exchange when rail and some ferry come on board at the end of the year. Some time down the track there will be a nationally based card. So, really, one swap out with added functionality.

    1. I upgrade the software on my computer from time to time, but i certainly don’t have to swap out the fingerprint reader when i do so, or the mouse or the keyboard. Sure, 10, 15 years down the track the reader may no longer be supported by the latest operating systems, but if a PC i bought needed hardware replacing after 6 months i’d be returning it under warrenty.

      Smart cards are pretty simple devices these days, the smarts are in backend software, and upgrades to the backend software shouldn’t require new cards.

      Like has already been said here, you are right big bang is not they way to go, but london shows the way forward, introduce one card, and roll out more functionality progressively through back end software upgrades.

      This snapper hop debacle is a branding nightmare, Infratil should have been left to roll out their snapper on their own if they so desired. Then commuters would only be mad at nz bus for rolling out a new system when it’s about to be replaced by the true hop card.

      1. 100% agree.

        It’s becoming clearer there was absolutely no sense in co-branding the Hop/Snapper card. NZ Bus should have been left to roll out Snapper if they so desired, with the Hop brand being launched only when the actual Hop card is.

        I also appreciate that this has to be a staged rollout, but, come on, asking everyone to replace their cards within a few months of issue is absolutely non-sensical and just a horrendous waste of plastic.

        Not one Aucklander I’ve talked to about Hop or Snapper understands much about it all, and the general consensus out there is that it’s all just too confusing. But we live in a city where challenging this is met with defensive and unclear answers rather than anyone ever admitting that maybe it wasn’t quite done right. The attitude is rubbish.

        Someone from Snapper mentioned to me that they and AT are releasing a joint FAQ – can’t come soon enough.

      2. 100% agree.

        It’s becoming clearer there was absolutely no sense in co-branding the Hop/Snapper card. NZ Bus should have been left to roll out Snapper if they so desired, with the Hop brand being launched only when the actual Hop card is.

        I also appreciate that this has to be a staged rollout, but, come on, asking everyone to replace their cards within a few months of issue is absolutely non-sensical and just a horrendous waste of plastic.

        Not one Aucklander I’ve talked to about Hop or Snapper understands much about it all, and the general consensus out there is that it’s all just too confusing. But we live in a city where challenging this is met with defensive and unclear answers rather than anyone ever admitting that maybe it wasn’t quite done right. The attitude is rubbish.

        Someone from Snapper mentioned to me that they and AT are releasing a joint FAQ – can’t come soon enough.

    2. Hi Sharon, Auckland Transport

      Just a query from a non-NZ person. Is there any chance that integrated ticketing (one ticket for all modes and operators) and integrated fares (one price for the journey, regardless of mode) and free transfers will be implemented on paper ticketing within, say the next 5 years or so?

      Thank you.
      BrisUrbane

    3. Sharon, I would suggest not being so defensive when people comment on how much of a shambles this all appears to the public. It’s not personal, just an observation from people who know precisely as much (really, as little) as is able to be clearly understood from what’s been made public. And if people in here think it’s a dog’s breakfast, that gives you some idea of how much worse it appears to the majority of the public who just want a transport system that “just bloody works”, don’t read the transport blogs, don’t read the FAQs on websites, etc.

      Also, please don’t try and analogise this with software upgrades. Replacing the card is the equivalent of replacing your phone or laptop, not of updating the software.

      I understand the HOP/Snapper replacement, but all this says is that, as others here have said, you shouldn’t have gone down the co-branded route at all. Rather, you should’ve left Infratil/NZ Bus to play their petty games and then rolled out HOP all in one hit. Let the customers get mad at NZ Bus for their BS, instead of being dragged into it. From that point on any upgrades should be possible without having to touch the cards that transport users have, since it’s all smarts on the back-end computer that make the fancy stuff possible.

      PS: We really do appreciate you engaging with this community. Please take what we say as constructive, and try to find ways to incorporate what we say into Auckland Transport’s future direction. We’re mostly not “experts”, just end users, so we speak from an asphalt-roots perspective that AT would do well to consider as it defines its role and direction. If you can sell it to us, you can sell it to pretty much any user.

  8. Hi Matt- understand only too well engaging with the end users- snd do take feedback as constructive. All helpful to get us to the end product.

    Cheers
    Sharon

  9. Hi BrisUrbane

    1. Auckland’s smartcard- HOP- will be introduced in total in just over eighteen months- the end of 2012.
    From there, international best practice says- let theticket bed in- then introduce a zonal fare system- I don’t have the definitive answer on the latter at this point.

    Sharon

    1. End of 2012??? I thought the project timelines had HOP being introduced in late 2011/early 2012 on the trains with full rollout on all buses, trains and ferries by late 2012. Or is that what you mean Sharon?

  10. Sharon – Are you able to say why it is taking so long to impliement. My understanding was that this was a relatively off the shelf system which should have made it fairly quick and easy to get up and running. The contract was let well over a year ago and if completion of just the hardware stage is going to take another 18 months I really question what has been going on behind the scenes as it isn’t like we have a complicated existing system we are trying to make it work together with. There are many companies undertaking much larger IT projects which have a far bigger impact on the entire country that are happening within a fraction of the time.

    Are the delays due to the operators pushing back, perhpaps large amounts of customisation that will make it hard to upgrade in the future or just bad project managment?

    1. A change of horse midstream (the rise and rise of Megatropolis), if you’ll pardon the awkward metaphor, probably hasn’t helped. Toss in an intransigent majority player in the bus market that is owned by a company that’s throwing its toys because it failed to win the tender, and you have the makings of a very complicated political environment. Especially when the relevant Minister is a fan of big business, has stated his preference for the local product and its owner, and has expressed his reluctance to assist local bodies in dealing with operators who play rough.

  11. Matt: AT and Snapper’s agreement for Auckland: HOP is for public transport, Snapper is for small purchases.

    Sharon

  12. The Auckland Ticketing program is not late, it’s on-track. Thales, has met and continues to meet all major milestones. Thales has already begun civil works on key stations as part of the system roll out.

    There is more to an integrated, multi-modal, multi-operator ticketing system than installing machines on one mode of transport, with one operator. This program is not realy about hardware, Thales is delivering an integrated multi-modal (bus, train, ferry) and multi-operator ticketing system, developed in line with fare policies, including a clearing house that will manage revenue / data distribution requirements etc.

    AT and Thales will continue to provide more detail about the ticketing system, the project milestones and technologies to demonstrate and present the system, the levels of integration / interoperability (across operators and modes) etc.

    Thales has over 40 years experience in delivering public transport ticketing programs around the world and has won numerous international awards for project management, innovation and engineering excellence.

    Emily Holborow
    Marketing & Communications Manager – Thales

    1. Thanks for stopping by Emily

      I realise there is more to it than just sticking up a few ticket readers however I just don’t understand why it will take 3 years to get it all rolled out. As I said it isn’t like this is the first city that has ever done it and we won’t be the first city with multiple different parties involved. The company I work for is currently doing a project that is far bigger in scope than what this would be, merging one core system into another, completely changing many parts of the business including every process and most internal and external terminology, impacting millions of customers and having to retrain over thousands of staff all within 8-9 months. If a project that size can be done in that timeframe why will this take so long?

  13. I don’t know why so many commenters here and elsewhere are acting like this is the end of the world! It seems that we’ll have to swap cards twice instead of once. So what? Swapping cards is easy; it doesn’t matter. And as for fully integrated fares taking a couple of years to implement, operations of this size are difficult and they will always take time.

    Despite a bit of confusion in the media, this project will be a huge benefit to Auckland, so be positive about it for crying out loud.

    The only thing I can’t figure out is why Infratil is introducing HOP/Snapper, only to have it swapped out a few months after launch. What’s in it for them?

  14. I remember when the contract stuff was all going down that there was talk that Infratil may introduce Snapper onto NZ Bus as a spoiling tactic in advance of the chosen provider if they did not win the contract as they were looking at replacing the current NZ Bus ticketing system anyways. It looks like what we’re seeing is a little less ‘clean’ than the ideal of the Thales system being the only one ever used in Auckland, but that all parties are on the same page and the NZ Bus ticketing replacement can go ahead on schedule. It does however raise the question if the project cost is going to be greater than would have otherwise been the case due to the HOP branded Snappers being introduced in advance of the Thales cards and the additional swap this entails..

  15. This real spanner in the works is that by this time next year… perhaps a bit later… almost all smart phones (iPhones/ htc/ Windows phones) will have a near-field communication device in them anyway. Give me an iPhone app over a card for this any day.

    This is all happening years too late.

  16. So can someone advise when it will be actually used on the go west / buses to PT Chev routes as I am only catching the bus once a week or so at the moment and I need to know if I should top up my go rider again or not.
    Is it meant to be by the end of April which doesnt leave much time?

  17. I really wonder if there will ever be a fully integrated ticketing system. Considering the Supercity managed to rework all its IT systems in around 9 months three years for Hop to get working fully is overly long. There is another election in 2013 and it is quite possible that a new council will not be as favourable to Transport plans. I am sure Infratil will be angling to become the sole operator in Auckland area in the next round of Traport Tenders and if they are Snapper will be the only ticketing choice.
    No need for any backoffice system as they already have it.

    1. Actually, the merger of Megatropolis IT is far from completed. Much of it is a dog’s breakfast. Many things have been done that are very sub-optimal, and will require remediation over a number of years. It was cobbled together in a matter of months, with consultants given a duty of “Make it happen”. A week before 1 November there were some pretty serious, realistic concerns in the hierarchy of the ATA that some systems would crash and burn horribly.

      So, no, you cannot use Auckland Council as an example of anything. Mostly it’s just tying together systems from the old councils, with a long-term view to spending lots of money on consultants to sort out the shambles and produce a high-quality IT infrastructure.

      1. I actually think we should give Super Council some credit for what they achieved. The disparate library come on line when it should and all systems worked. The rates system seems to have worked OK from day one, and they managed to roll out SAP which is no mean task but it was ready from the first day. I don’t care if the had lots of consultants or not but the system worked and they should get some acknowledgement for that. Which makes it all the more strange that it is taking three plus years to roll out integrated ticketing.

        1. Oh, absolutely full credit. I worked with some of the consultants, and reviewed some of their work. They’ve done a stellar job. My point was more that the job is far from complete, and a lot of the reason they achieved what they did was that they just whacked together some interfaces between the existing systems. Replacing the legacy with a coherent whole will take many years.

          HOP, on the other hand, has no existing installed systems from which to leverage. It’s a greenfield deployment, and the scope to work around implementation failures is greatly reduced from that of a greenfield SAP implementation. You can’t just fill in a paper form on the side of the road if the card reader fails and the passenger doesn’t have cash.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *