Submissions closed last week on the proposed changes to bus routes in inner Auckland. I look forward to seeing the outcomes of the consultation and whether Auckland Transport still proceed with the proposed changes – I do hope so, as long as the changes are accompanied by necessary infrastructure works to ensure the “Outer Loop” route is reliable. In the comments thread of one of the posts I made on the changes, a representative of the Eden Terrace business association suggested an interesting alternative to the routes – that I think is worth sharing and discussing: For a comparison, this is what’s being proposed by Auckland Transport: As far as I can see, the ETBA propose three changes:

  • Extending the Inner City service southwards from Karangahape Road to Newton Road in Eden Terrace.
  • Re-routing the northern part of the Link Route so that instead of travelling along Wellesley Street and through the University it would go along Victoria Street, Albert Street and then Customs Street and Beach Road before making its way to Parnell.
  • Re-routing the “Outer Loop” bus between Newmarket and Britomart to travel via Khyber Pass Road and Symonds Street, rather than via Parnell.

While obviously the proposed changes are intended to improve bus access to Eden Terrace, and one wouldn’t expect anything different from an business organisation representing that area, they also potentially have some merit and I think are worth having a bit of a think about one by one.

  • Inner City Service Extension:

This proposed change is most obviously for the benefit of the Eden Terrace area, linking them in with the city centre to a greater extent. The route extension is likely to mean that it’s necessary to either have an extra bus or two running the route, or to operate it at lower frequencies.

I think that ultimately when deciding about this extension we need to make a call on whether the Newton/Eden Terrace area is part of the city centre or not. With the proposed Newton train station as part of the CBD, plus the enormous potential of the area for intensification and greater development, I think that in the longer term it could be part of an extended city centre – perhaps including some sort of ‘capping’ of the motorway between the Symonds Street and Upper Queen Street bridges.

I would probably lean away from this particular service extension at this point of time, mainly because there is a huge number of buses already connecting the city with Eden Terrace (all the New North, Sandringham, Dominion and Mt Eden Road buses) so I don’t see too much gain for the extra resources expended. However, in the longer term if we are to bring Newton/Eden Terrace into the city centre properly then the route extension really starts to make sense.

  • Link Bus Changes:

The change proposed pushes the Link to service the northern part of the city centre to a greater extent, travelling via Britomart rather than the University. While there’s obviously a bit of a loss in not having the Link pass by the University anymore (this is compensated by having the Outer Loop pass by the Uni) there’s an argument that having the Link in the northern part of the city centre more than compensates for this.

In my submission I noted some concern about the Link having poor coverage of the central city,with both of its east-west crossings of Queen Street being to the south of where most employment activity is. The EBTA proposal would certainly fix that, by running the Link along Customs Street instead of Wellesley Street. Overall I quite like the change – although potential bottlenecks along Albert Street and Customs Street probably need to be addressed, while it also requires the re-routing of the Outer Loop service to ensure the University is properly served.

  • Outer Loop Changes:

The main change is pulls the Outer Loop out of Parnell and sends it via Khyber Pass Road and Symonds Street to Britomart instead. It’s hard to know whether that would result in a slower trip or a faster trip to cover the Newmarket to Britomart journey (via Parnell is probably shorter, but with less bus priority). One big advantage of this option is that it puts the university on the Outer Loop bus – thereby providing good connectivity to the university for anyone along this quite extensive route.

While I realise the EBTA want more buses to travel via Eden Terrace, I do wonder whether this Outer Loop change might work a bit better if the bus followed the Central Connector route past the Hospital and over Grafton Bridge – as the extensive bus priority measures through here might speed things up a bit.

Overall, the suggested changes are quite interesting and I think they’re well worth some serious consideration. For me, looking at the alterations holistically there seems some benefit in sending the Outer Loop bus via the university and some benefit from having the Link bus serve the northern part of the city centre. Whether that’s worth the negative aspect of not having the Link bus pass by the university, or the longer travel time the Link bus and potentially the Outer Loop bus might have, is something that I probably can’t really answer – but would certainly consider with interest what others think.

Share this

7 comments

  1. Over 50,000 people study at the two universities. While they certainly aren’t the only game in town, their weight in terms of passenger numbers means that delinking the Link from them will require large uptake on other transport options. I’d need to be convinced.

    1. Yes very true George. I guess the question is whether the university gains more from being on the Outer Loop than it loses from not being on the Link.

  2. The Link situation just highlights what a sick mess NZTA have made of Grafton Gully. There is no way to travel the obvious and intuitive route from Parnell to the Uni or the Domain to the city, using any means imaginal; car, bus, boat, bike, foot. The single minded truck-heads have really excelled themselves here; so convoluted, so expensive, so ugly, so useless…. What to do? It’s a good idea to get the Link through the middle of campus… does it really need to go downtown to tangle with every other bus?…. is that idea because of the need for everything to go to our one train station, I mean; terminus? I’m not sure, if you’re on the Link, and I often am, is it to get to a train? I quite like the new proposed route as it is, it looks fast-ish…. a bit of a walk down Queen ain’t no thing….. and avoiding Customs St is a good idea. I’m not sure you give a reason for favouring your northern route Admin?

    1. I like having the Link more to the north because I think it really needs to be in the heart of the CBD. Personally I tend to think of the corner of Queen and Victoria streets as being the real centre of the city. Having the Link wholly to the south seems unbalanced.

      Unscientific I know, but what is proposed by Auckland Transport for the Link just feels unbalanced.

  3. The alternative routes chosen were taking into account Auckland Transports requirements outlined to the ETBA. These were to have a connection between Parnell Rd and Britomart, that the Link route had to use the Central Connector via the Hospital, and that there had to be a stop near St Kevin’s arcade. We also thought Victoria St and the Sky tower should be access-able, and that the University should be served by the loop service rather than adding extra high frequency buses between Britomart and the Uni.

    The majority of our buses are B-Line with mid town destinations and few downtown services which get over loaded when they pick up. Eden Terrace locals would prefer a better link between our area, Ponsonby, Newmarket and Downtown. We see Eden Terrace as a growing entertainment district with top restaurants and small to medium sized concert venues that should have a legible connection with the CBD, of which we are now included in as part of the Waitemata Board. This gives Aucklanders and tourists alike another choice along side Ponsonby and Parnell as destinations.

  4. The regeneration of Eden Terrace retail/entertainment strip would happen at a quicker rate if there were more bus services including a connection to Ponsonby and the city.This would also be well supported by tourists ans well as Aucklanders It should reduce car traffic from Ponsonby to this area if concert goers had confidence in a bus services.

  5. Auckland Transport has received a submission from the Eden Terrace Business Association in regards to their proposed alternative routes. The submission will be considered along with all other consultation feedback and issues raised in blogs such as this.

    The consultation period closed on Friday 15 April 2011. Auckland Transport will review all the feedback received and use it to make final route and service level decisions.

    Final decisions and how we used the feedback will be made available at http://www.maxx.co.nz/centralchanges and communicated in a range of ways to bus users before any changes are implemented.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *